Personal Injury Lawyer &
Worker's Comp Attorney

816-400-4878

Personal Injury Insurance Actions in Missouri and a New Definition of ‘Reasonable Value’

Monday, Jun. 3rd 2019

By Nick Daugherty

A change in a Missouri state statute has created a new, interpretable definition of reasonable value of medical care in personal injury litigation. Although the change was likely intended to provide more clarity, competing Missouri decisions interpreting the new statute have created some confusion when it comes to pre-amendment cases.

How Missouri courts resolve the question of whether the amendment applies retroactively will have significant implications as to the potential exposure insurers face in actions to recover contractual insurance benefits following an accident.

In Missouri personal injury actions, an injured plaintiff may recover damages as compensation for medical treatment received following an accident. However, the admissibility of evidence regarding the “reasonable value” of treatment is governed by state statute (Section 490.715.5, RSMo), which was amended a year ago.

Previously, there was a rebuttable presumption under Missouri law that the dollar amount necessary to satisfy the financial obligation to the healthcare provider represented the value of the medical treatment received.

The bar for rebutting this presumption was low, leading plaintiffs to offer testimony that the amounts charged or billed represented the reasonable value of those services. Plaintiffs could potentially be awarded the full amounts of the medical charges, even when such charges had been written off or contractually adjusted.

Under current Missouri law, parties may only introduce evidence of the “actual cost” of the medical treatment rendered to the plaintiff. The statute now defines the actual cost as the sum of money actually paid to the healthcare provider plus any remaining dollar amount necessary to satisfy the financial obligation to the provider for such treatment. There is no longer an avenue under the amended statute for plaintiffs to introduce evidence of the full amount billed in an attempt to recover amounts not actually paid or actually due and owing.

In actions against automobile insurance carriers following an accident, many plaintiffs attempted to circumvent this change by filing actions before the amendment’s effective date in hopes of benefitting under the prior version. Missouri courts have since confronted the question of whether the new statute applies equally to such pre-amendment cases, and courts have come to competing conclusions.

Some Missouri courts have found that the amendment to the statute effected merely a procedural or remedial change to the evidentiary code. Because the amendment does not fundamentally change a party’s substantive rights, those courts have concluded that the new statute may be applied to existing causes of action.

Other courts have found that because the plaintiff’s claim against the insurance carrier is based in contract, the law that applied at the time of the injury controls. They reasoned that at the time of such a pre-amendment accident, plaintiffs arguably had a contractual right to potentially recover the full amount billed, concluding that the amendment effected a substantive change in the law and may not be applied retroactively in such cases.

As a result, an insurance company’s potential exposure could be significantly affected, depending upon the date of the accident. Additionally, as a practical matter, the value an insurer places on a claim could have implications as to that insurer’s exposure for statutory penalties arising from a “vexatious refusal” to pay benefits under a policy. Consequently, the inconsistent rulings on this issue may impact the way in which insurance adjusters evaluate an insured’s claim for benefits.

For example, if the insurer calculates the value of a particular claim based upon the lower “actual cost” of the medical treatment for a pre-amendment accident, the injured plaintiff may point to any resulting settlement offer as evidence of the insurer’s vexatious conduct in light of the significantly higher amount billed for the medical services received. On the other hand, if the insurer values the claim based upon the billed amounts despite the statutory amendment only allowing evidence of the “actual cost” of those services, the insurer may overvalue its exposure for a claim, thereby paying more benefits than the insured would be legally entitled to recover otherwise.

If you’ve been injured and aren’t sure where to turn, let us help. We represent individuals in many areas of personal injury including truck, auto and motorcycle accidents, property liability (slip & fall), spinal cord injuries, and more. For a free consultation please call (816)-400-4878. If you have further questions do not hesitate to reach out to us by phone number, through the contact form, or even with the live chat option listed on our site!


Personal Injury

If you’ve been injured and aren’t sure where to turn, let us help. We represent individuals in many areas of personal injury including truck, auto and motorcycle accidents, property liability (slip & fall), spinal cord injuries, and more.

Worker's Comp

Injured at work? We can help! If you have suffered a work-related injury or illness, we can help ensure you get full and fair compensation under the law.

HELPING THE INJURED-PROTECTING THE COMMUNITY

Our Personal Injury & Worker's Comp Attorneys

Northland Injury Law: Personal Injury Lawyers in Northland Kansas City and Northwest Missouri.

Proudly serving: Gladstone, Liberty, Kansas City, North Kansas City, Saint Joseph, Plattsburg, Cameron, Chillicothe, Trenton, Sedalia, Warrensburg and many other areas in Missouri.

The Northland Injury Law Firm has been practicing in the Kansas City area for many years. Our founders, Max Von Erdsmannsdorff and Steve Mowry, built a strong foundation for the firm. Since Eric Bartlett joined the firm in 1996, Northland Injury Law has earned a reputation for success, honesty and compassion in personal injury and worker’s compensation.

I found Northland Injury Law to be very professional and honest! They kept me up to date on my case. I would highly recommend the whole firm for all your legal needs!!” – Michael T.

Northland Injury Law is proud of the relationships they’ve built with the clients they have served in the Northland and surrounding areas.  Their many great results for seriously injured people have helped their clients recover the significant economic losses that attend such serious injuries.

When it comes to a lawsuit after an accident or injury, representation matters! Most people do not realize that insurance companies have teams of lawyers, investigators, photographers and defense experts who immediately go to work following a serious accident involving their insureds.  They hire these people to minimize their exposure throughout the claims process and to reduce the amount received by the victim. Northland Injury Law aims to level the playing field for their clients.

This is an excellent law firm. They helped me out after an accident and did an awesome job. I would recommend this law firm to anyone who needs a good lawyer.” – Toni B.

Between them, Mr. Mowry and Mr. Bartlett have over  50 combined years of legal experience in the Kansas City Northland area. They have both been recognized by KC Magazine as “Top attorneys in Missouri and Kansas” and both have been recognized in the National Top 100 Trial Attorneys.

If you require the services of excellent local lawyers after an accident or injury, call Northland Injury Law today for a free consultation at 816-400-4878.

Latest Blog

Employee injured after crash into store

ST JOSEPH, Mo.– A Missouri store employee was injured when a pick-up truck crashed into a Dollar Tree Wednesday, July 24. It happened at around 2 p.m. while the driver of that vehicle was inside shopping. She had left her...

Read More

Frequently Asked Questions

Get answers about our Kansas City law firm, like how and when to file a suit for your Personal Injury & Worker’s Compensation.

View All FAQ's
Northland Injury Law © All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy

Site Created by KC Web Specialists, LLC